She engineered her own sale.
Thomas felt sick.
“What do you want?” he asked.
“I want what was stolen from me,” she replied. “I want my brother and sister to know I exist. I want your church friends to know you bought your own stepdaughter as property.”
Revenge had driven her. But reality proved more complicated than hatred alone.
A House Divided
Thomas moved Sarah into the main house under the pretense that she would serve as a personal maid.
Margaret welcomed the elegant new servant. Richard, visiting briefly from Richmond, noticed her unusual bearing and education.
Sarah played her role flawlessly in public — obedient, efficient.
In private, she forced Thomas to confront truths he had never examined.
She told him about Catherine’s letters. About the uncle who had forced himself upon a sixteen-year-old girl. About a family that chose reputation over justice.
“Did you forgive her?” Thomas asked once.
Sarah answered honestly.
“I loved her because she was my mother. But forgive her? I don’t know if I have that kind of grace.”
Margaret eventually sensed the tension. Richard saw the resemblance and confronted his father angrily, assuming scandal of another kind.
Thomas could not explain.
He was paralyzed between shame and responsibility.
A Crisis of Conscience
The weight of the revelation did something unexpected.
Thomas began reading abolitionist literature in secret. He attended quiet Quaker gatherings in neighboring counties. For the first time in his life, he considered the possibility that slavery itself — not merely individual cruelty — was evil.
Six months after purchasing Sarah, he made a decision that stunned Caroline County.
He filed papers to manumit her.
Freeing a healthy enslaved woman worth $750 was considered madness. It threatened the entire social order.
Virginia law required freed slaves to leave the state within one year or risk re-enslavement. Thomas now faced another dilemma: freeing Sarah meant losing her again.
And for Sarah, freedom did not feel simple either.
Revenge had fueled her for years. But now she had witnessed Thomas’s remorse and seen his transformation.
Leave a Comment